Published:
Dr. Bindu Ranaut on Motherhood, Boundaries and the Conversations Families Leave Unsaid
Some of the most important conversations between mothers and daughters begin years after the moment they are actually about. A rule that once felt unfair, a night out that ended in an argument, or a decision a mother believed was protective can look very different with time, especially when both people remember the same moment from opposite sides.
Dr. Bindu Ranaut has spent much of her professional life thinking about how people communicate. An educator for more than 25 years, she is also a writer, poet, mother, published researcher, and a familiar member of the Sanskar Savvy community. Through our SALA coverage, readers may also recognize her as an interviewer who has helped South Asian writers and artists speak about identity, heritage, creativity, and the experiences behind their work.
This Sanskar Session turns the conversation toward Ranaut. Leading the conversation is Feny Pandya, one of Sanskar Savvy’s longtime community members and feature writers. Pandya has contributed cultural and entertainment coverage to Sanskar for years, and her perspective as a daughter becomes an important part of the discussion.
Together, Ranaut and Pandya explore the ideas behind Ranaut’s book, “I’m Sorry I Said No: Lessons about Bond, Boundaries, and Becoming,” published in 2026. The book reflects on the rules, refusals, expectations, and protective acts that can shape the relationship between mothers and daughters.
For Ranaut, the subject begins with something she learned through decades of teaching: “People remember stories long after they forget lessons.” The same principle guides the book. She is not offering a parenting formula. She is looking closely at ordinary family moments, especially in South Asian households where love may be expressed through sacrifice, protection, responsibility, and rules more often than through direct explanation.
That makes this conversation especially fitting for Celebrate, Explore, Connect! We can celebrate what our families gave us, explore the expectations we inherited with those gifts, and connect by finding better ways to say what love does not always make easy to express.
When Love, Protection and Control Begin to Blur
Ranaut grew up with an understanding of love that many South Asian homes will recognize. Parents gave generously, children were expected to respect those sacrifices, and protection was one of the clearest expressions of care.
“Love needs room to breathe,” Ranaut said. “I grew up in a culture where love is shown through sacrifice.”
Becoming a mother forced her to think more carefully about what happens when that protection meets a child’s growing independence.
“I came to see that love and control can look very similar from the outside,” she said. A mother may set a boundary because she fears something could happen to her daughter, while the daughter may experience that same boundary as mistrust. Both can be responding honestly to the same moment while hearing different messages.
The title “I’m Sorry I Said No” was intentional. Ranaut explained that many people struggle to say both no and sorry, especially when boundaries cause hurt or disappointment. “So many of us apologize for our boundaries,” she said, even when the boundary itself may have been necessary.
“A boundary isn’t a rejection of love,” Ranaut explained. “It can be a thing that lets love last longer.”
She sees the mother-daughter relationship as especially complicated because each woman carries more history than either may realize. A mother can see her own childhood, hopes, fears, and relationship with her mother reflected in her daughter. A daughter may look to her mother as her first example of what it means to be a woman.
“A mother says, ‘I’m only trying to protect you,’ and the daughter hears, ‘You’re not enough as you are,’” Ranaut said.
Pandya recognized that tension from the daughter’s side. She reflected on how adulthood can change the way children see their parents. Parents who once seemed to have every answer eventually become visible as people moving through each stage of life for the first time too.
Ranaut arrived at a similar understanding through motherhood. Writing the book caused her to revisit her own upbringing and reconsider some of the boundaries her mother had set. She began to understand her mother with more compassion while also acknowledging that she would handle some of her own decisions differently now.
“I realized I was never going to be a perfect mother, and that perfection isn’t what the children need,” she said. “They need us to be real, and willing to say, ‘I’m still learning too.’”
Looking back, Ranaut put that idea even more personally: “I was growing up with you as well.”
Keep the Values and Explain the Why
Ranaut and Pandya’s conversation turns to a question many South Asian families know well: how can parents preserve culture and family values while allowing children to develop identities of their own?
Ranaut begins by separating values from rules. Kindness, respect, gratitude, care for family, and consideration for others may remain deeply important, even when the exact rules previous generations used to teach those values no longer fit in the same way.
“I try to explain the why behind every tradition instead of just saying because we’ve always done this,” she told Pandya. “When children understand the meaning, they often choose to keep it and do it in their own way.”
That distinction matters especially for immigrant and diaspora families. Parents may try to preserve traditions that connected them to family, community, or life in India, while their children grow up in North America with different social expectations and ideas about independence.
Ranaut does not see questioning a tradition as abandoning it. She asks families to explain what the tradition was meant to teach. If the value is respect, what does respect look like now? If the goal is safety, can a parent explain the fear behind a rule? If a family practice matters because it keeps generations connected, can children understand that purpose and still participate in a way that feels like their own?
“We guide them, but we don’t own them,” Ranaut said. “Our job is to give them roots and then trust them with their own wings.”
Her own daughter has played a major role in teaching Ranaut what that kind of relationship requires. After years of educating others, Ranaut said motherhood taught her some of her hardest communication lessons.
“Children don’t care about your credentials,” she said. “For them, you are a parent. They watch you live.”
Ranaut described herself as someone who once became quiet when she was hurt or frustrated, but her daughter challenged that habit.
“She has taught me not to keep things to myself and sulk about them, but be open to communication,” Ranaut said.
That meant doing more than explaining her own feelings. Ranaut began asking her daughter questions too: How did you feel about what I said? What could I have done differently? What would make this better?
Communication became less about a parent delivering the final answer and more about understanding what both people had experienced. Ranaut calls children “our toughest and most loving teachers.”
Why the Blank Pages Matter
One of the most distinctive choices in “I’m Sorry I Said No” is visible before the reader writes a single response. Ranaut intentionally left pages blank, so the book would belong partly to the person holding it, not just to her own story.
“This book isn’t meant to be just mine,” she explained. “I didn’t want it to say, ‘Oh, this is Bindu’s book,’ or ‘This is a book about Bindu and her daughter.’”
The pages invite mothers and daughters to add what their own relationship brings to the subject. A reader might write down a memory, an apology, a thank you, a moment that still hurts, or something she hopes to do differently in another generation.
“The blank pages are an invitation,” Ranaut said. “Pause, breathe, and write what you have never said.”
Some of those pages look forward too. Ranaut invites daughters to consider what they may one day want to say or do differently with their own children, turning reflection on one generation into a question for the next.
The book can also give families something to begin with when a direct conversation feels too difficult. Ranaut does not suggest resolving years of disagreements at once. Instead, she recommends starting with one chapter, one memory, or one rule that once caused an argument.
Ranaut has used stories this way in her own family. She watches Bollywood movies with her daughter and sometimes pauses when a scene touches on family, relationships, expectations, or something they have experienced themselves. Talking about what someone else is going through first can make it easier to move toward their own experiences.
“Rather than being the teacher, or rather than being the mother, just be the friend,” Ranaut said.
Pandya recognized how closely that advice connects to something Ranaut said at the beginning of their conversation: people remember stories long after they forget lessons. By the end of the interview, Ranaut described how those same stories can help families start conversations that direct instruction sometimes cannot.
Two Questions Worth Taking Home
When the conversation turned to what mothers and daughters might say after reading the book together, Ranaut offered two questions: “What did you need from me that I did not know how to give?” and “What are you proud of, and what do you wish you had said?”
Both invite a conversation about the past without requiring either person to prove that her memory is the correct one. The first gives a daughter room to name something she needed while allowing a mother to acknowledge that she may not have known how to provide it. The second leaves room for pride, regret, and words that may have been felt but never spoken.
Those conversations can be especially difficult in families where affection is expressed more easily through actions than words. Love may arrive as food, rides, phone calls, advice, sacrifice, concern, practical help, or a parent waiting awake until a child comes home. Saying “I’m proud of you,” “I was scared,” “I’m sorry,” “I needed something different,” or even “I love you” may be less familiar.
Ranaut’s book makes room for both. She writes as a mother looking back on the reasons behind some of her noes, while her conversation with Pandya adds the daughter’s perspective from the other side. Pandya recognizes what Ranaut describes while also asking what mothers can learn from the children they raise.
That exchange makes this Sanskar Session especially personal. Both women have joined the Sanskar Savvy community in different ways. Ranaut has shared her experience as an educator, writer, interviewer, and cultural voice, while Pandya has supported Sanskar for years and contributed her own features. Here, they bring mother-and-daughter perspectives into the same conversation without asking readers to accept either one as the complete story.
Their discussion also brings Celebrate, Explore, Connect! into a part of family life that can be difficult to put into words. We Celebrate the love and sacrifices our families have given us, Explore the rules, expectations, and boundaries that may deserve another conversation, and Connect when we become willing to hear what the same family history looked like from someone else’s side.
Ranaut does not suggest that one conversation can repair every misunderstanding between a mother and daughter. Her approach is smaller and more practical: start with one chapter, one movie, one lunch, one memory, one question, or even one blank page in her book, and give each other enough room to answer.
Stay Connected With Sanskar Sessions
This conversation with Dr. Bindu Ranaut is part of Sanskar Sessions, our continuing series of interviews with the writers, artists, creators, and community voices helping shape the stories we share.
At Sanskar Savvy, we want these conversations to continue beyond a single article. Celebrate, Explore, Connect! with us as we share more stories from our community, introduce you to the people behind the work, and create more opportunities to listen, learn, and connect with one another.
Stay connected with Sanskar Savvy for more Sanskar Sessions, community stories, interviews, cultural coverage, and the voices we believe are worth knowing.